Tuesday, November 06, 2007

Is there a more meaningless award than the "Gold Glove?"

MLB's Gold Glove awards were announced this afternoon, with two Tigers winning. Though one of the Tigers' winners was not the correct choice, just the expected choice.

Pudge Rodriguez won his umpteenth gold glove, most undeservedly. At this point of his career, he's going to win a gold glove every season, until he retires, just because he's "Pudge." At this point, Pudge is winning via voter muscle memory, rather than anything he's done on the field. The managers and coaches sure as Hell ignored his struggles behind the plate this past season.

Placido Polanco won his first gold glove, and I'm sure everyone will agree that it was most deserved. The Placidome is a fielding machine. He hasn't made an error since tee ball.

Curits Granderson, who played the best defensive center field in all of baseball, was, to put it bluntly, royally screwed.

The AL outfielders to win were Torii Hunter (Winning on pure momentum, much like Pudge), Grady Sizemore (The MSM's "It" player, and a media darling, even though Granderson had a much better season), and Ichiro (His winning keeps the Japanese fan base happy).

I'm sure Granderson will someday win a Gold Glove. Unfortunately, it'll be after he has another freakish offensive season (You know you have to be a good offensive player in order to win a defensive award), or gets a career achievement Gold Glove sometime in his mid 30's, once the voters get tired of giving the award to Sizemore.

I'm not even going to touch on Brandon Inge, the 3rd base human highlight reel...

Due to the outmoded voting procedures, the Gold Glove is the most overrated award in sports. Is it really an honor to win, when the voters are making such uninformed, clueless choices?

1 comment:

  1. Big Al ~ "Due to the outmoded voting procedures, the Gold Glove is the most overrated award in sports. Is it really an honor to win, when the voters are making such uninformed, clueless choices?"

    *****
    I can't say as know how the voting process works for the GG award, but if you are going to give the award to the best defensive player at each position, except pitcher, should you not be using stats? Should it not be given to the player who has the best fielding percentage, based on a preordained number of chances? I will have to do some research on this...

    But to say it is overrated and meaningless is harsh. Go ask Placido if he feels honored to win this award. I bet he says yes.

    ReplyDelete